Luca Gardini: 95 points

“An estate dating back to the early nineteenth century, now run by Filippo Fanti, capable of investing firmly in brand production. The result, among others, is this striking Brunello that is both savoury and intense with wonderful persistence. Spiciness on the nose: sweet violet, raspberry, a hint of pepper leaf. The mouth discovers its sapidity and tautness.” – Luca Gardini

Review date: October 2020

JamesSuckling.com: 95 points

“Lots of plum and dark-berry character with citrus, cedar and sandalwood. Very pure Sangiovese. Full-bodied with firm, racy tannins and cool, vivid fruit at the finish. Some mineral, tar and steel undertones. Needs time to open and soften. Better than the 2015. Try after 2023” – James Suckling

Review date: November 2020

Robert Parker's Wine Advocate: 94 points

“The 2016 Brunello di Montalcino offers clean and pristine fruit and otherwise delivers a textbook interpretation of the vintage. Given the large extension of vineyards farmed by this estate, which is located on the southern side of the appellation, and the deft technological approach employed in the winery, you can count on Castello Banfi to offer an authentic read of any of their wines about to hit the market or that have been aged at the back of your cellar. Indeed, the Banfi library of wines acts as an institutional memory of modern Brunello. This edition shows sharp and focused fruit with leather, potting soil and balsam herb. For a straight-up classic Brunello, this wine delivers the goods.” – Monica Larner

Review date: November 2020

Wine Enthusiast: 92 points

Camphor, rose and new leather aromas form the nose along with a whiff of baking spice on this vibrant red. Polished and taut, the savory palate offers spiced cranberry, red cherry and star anise before finishing on a coffee note. Lithe, refined tannins and fresh acidity provide balanced support. Drink 2022–2028.” – Kerin O’Keefe

Review date: May 2021